By law, Chief Gavin had to douse county fair fireworks display PDF Print
By Charlie Warner
Argus News Editor


“It was an extremely difficult decision, one that I really didn’t want to make, but the potential was there for property damage or even personal injury. After reviewing the situation, and discussing it with several other members of the fire department, I think we made the right call.”

That’s what Caledonia Fire Chief Chuck Gavin said about cancelling the fireworks display at the Houston County Fair. To commemorate the 150th year of the fair, the fair board decided to include a large fireworks display opening night, which was Wednesday, Aug. 13.

“The fair board went through the proper channels to obtain the permit,” City Administrator Bob Nelson said. “The fire department was asked to be on hand to provide fire protection. When they arrived several hours before the scheduled event, they looked everything over and felt it was a hazardous situation.”

According to Gavin, the fireworks were to be launched on the east end of the fair grounds near the grandstand. The projectiles were to be shot nearly straight up and potentially would be landing very close to a large LP tank, a 500 gallon diesel fuel tank, a 300 gallon gasoline tank, and near a herd of 150 beef cows.

“The permit was issued in June, but we never received any information from the company as to where they were going to launch the fireworks,” Gavin explained. “The code calls for at least 420 feet of clearance, and they were within 125 feet. We looked at moving the launching area closer to the grandstand, but that wouldn’t work either, because then it was too close to the spectators. I even contacted the state fire marshal. I was advised not to sign the papers to let the fireworks display go on as planned.”

According to Gavin, either he or Houston County Sheriff Doug Ely had to sign the final approval papers before the event could take place.

Gavin pointed out that the Caledonia Fire Department has always supported the Houston County Fair. Local fire fighters have helped provide fire protection and crowd control for more than 100 years, until the Fair Posse was established a number of years ago. 

“I didn’t want to deny the permit, but I didn’t have any choice,” Gavin continued. “The fair board went through the proper channels. It wasn’t their fault. The company that was putting the event on has it stated right on their website that they need a 300 foot radius around the launch site. They knew better. They didn’t have close to enough room. By law, we couldn’t approve it,” the fire chief concluded.

You can contact Charlie Warner at This e-mail address is being protected from spam bots, you need JavaScript enabled to view it
Comments (16)add
...
written by y , August 15, 2008
Yes, safety first We are sure it was a tuff decision but you did what was right for the community- Good job Chief Gavin! Your department does a great job - keep it up.
...
written by Connerned Citizen , August 15, 2008
We are sure this was a hard decision for you and your department, We are glad you know how important safety is. Thank you for making the right decision. The Fair will still go on with or with out fireworks. Thanks for all your department does Chief Gavin - you can be proud of your department and all the hard work your men do.
...
written by Agree , August 16, 2008
You did make the right decision. Just think if the fireworks did go on and something terrible happened....then it would have been much tougher for you and everyone would have wondered why safety wasn't considered first. Some of us remember the last fireworks in the 70's that were held in Caledonia on the 4th of July.....explosion, injury, law suits, etc. With your decision, you avoided the potential for all of that. Keep up the good work.
...
written by happy , August 16, 2008
Isn't that for the huge shells not the little one that were being shot at the fairgrounds and if you knew back then why didn't say something to the company that was suppose to shoot them off??? Kinda lame on the chief fault for not getting a hold of someone in the fireworks display that would make sure it was all good!! And to make sure it was all safe. You don't think the shooters and display people don't want it safe????? WTH!!!!!!!!!!!
...
written by Fae , August 17, 2008
I think the Argus should have tried to get a response from the fireworks company to see the other side of the story. When someone places blame on someone in a press release and the newspaper doesn't give the one blamed a chance to respond, I think it's not very professional or balanced.
...
written by just wondering , August 18, 2008
so now it is the fire cheifs job to make sure the people from the proffesional fireworks company did there job, come on!!! who hired them? shouldn't they oversee some? was all the paperwork even given to the cheif on the location? go to google type in charles city fireworks , see who put them on ?do we need that here?
...
written by da , August 18, 2008
It would seem obvious to me that maybe BEFORE we issue a permit, we would find out where they were launching them off from???????
come on Caledonia
...
written by jambalinglongshire , August 18, 2008
Listen 'happy', don't blame the chief. He's the one that saved your ass from possibly going up in smoke that night. You want someone to blame for your fizzled out fireworks plans, blame J&M. They're the idiots that didn't survey and look around to see if it was safe to have a massive fireworks display. THEY'RE the ones who didn't use common sense here, and obviously at that Charles City, Iowa explosion on the 4th.
It's not the fire chief's job to organize the fireworks. the firemen are there in case something goes wrong.
...
written by .... , August 18, 2008
WHO CARES??? All in all a very successful fair. If your going to complain about the fair in any way maybe u should get up of your butt and support it instead of just ragging on all that you didn't like. Fair board and all the people that tried to put on the fireworks show good job. You tried to bring something new to the fair. Thats always a good thing seeing new stuff at the fair. And there was a lot of new things that were very successful. Fire department, good call, way to many fire hazards i mean just look on the other side of the grandstands there was a plastic tent. Now how many fireworks shows have we all been to that embers don't hit the ground. And for all the people that rag on the fire-department when they get a new truck or anything. Its for your own safety after all they are the ones at 2 o'clock in the morning that put their own life's on the line to save you. SUPPORT THEM. FIre works some were for some were against personally i was against for not all the fire hazards but for all the animals at the fair. I mean come on now the animals were just moved the day off they are scared its a new place and allot of people around. There would have been a lot of problems in the cattle barns. But all in all a good fair. And i think we all need to do a better job supporting our local events instead of just bringing them down.. Good job to all who made it a successful fair.
...
written by long time fair goer , August 19, 2008
I don't blame the fire chief I feel he saved alot of people. If those fire works would have went off, it could have been a terrible tradgey. I don't blame J and M, I blame the fair board. This should have been put together better, analized better, and thought through... at what point did they think that shooting fireworks off in front of the grandstands was a good and safe place, there are fields all off to the side of the fair grounds that are open where no one would be injured or in danger including the animals in the barns. Spectators do not have to be in the fairgrounds to enjoy the display they easily could have seen from their homes or the street. And as far as the fair it's self, I have been to many fairs and this is the worst I've seen. It isn't a fair with out a ferris wheel. Bring TIP TOP back!!!
...
written by also long time fair goer , August 19, 2008
i agree with long time fair goer come on fair board were is your comin sence i think we need new blood on this board!also thanks to the fire chief good job well done! and maybe next time if any have it before the animals all go out there!
...
written by 4-Her , August 19, 2008
I'm sure everyone did what they di inthe best interst of the variuos groups concerned. Thank you to the fair board for attempting this, we understand you were sticking your necks out. Sorry the show didn't go on, but also glad all are safe. It'll be interesting to see how many of these people VOLUNTEER to put the fair on, to fight fires, to shoot fireworks, to be an adult leader to improve our community, county, state and country. Let them put thier thoughts to good use and quit cutting everyone down for trying to do something good
...
written by Woo Hoo , August 19, 2008
Seems a few people here should be less concerned with fairs and fireworks and work a bit on basic grammar.
...
written by new fair board directors welcome! :) , August 21, 2008
I wanted to say a few things on the comment that was made regarding needing "new blood" on the fair board. The fair board is a volunteer service and anyone who would like to join is more than welcome. Fair board meetings are the third Monday of each month! I think most people agree that this years carnival was less than perfect. What the less informed public needs to know is that if your county fair has a carnival this year, you should consider yourself lucky. Alot of carnivals have gone out of business this year, and the rural fairs are the ones hit the hardest. Take a step back and look at the economy right now and it's easy to see why companies like carnivals that run on fuel are suffering. I think we as a society need to quit playing the blame game.
...
written by * , August 21, 2008
I think this years fair was great! We brought our whole family and friends that were visiting and we all thought it was wonderful that there were so many activites going on throughout the day each day we were there. Great job fair volunteers and fire department! I, unlike some others, commend you on your hard work and dedication and appreciate everything you guys do to improve our community. You guys take alot of heat for being volunteers! Stick with it and know that the majority of the comunity appreciates your service!
...
written by ken miller , August 22, 2008
1st - I know the J M saleman that handled this. He files DOZENS of MN display permits EVERY year. EACH ONE of them includes a display site diagram, AS REQUIRED BY MN LAW. This was done in JUNE. Why were no problems where discovered until 30 minutes before show time. How did that happen? I'm guessing that that Mr. Gavin was not given the diagram. How is that J M's fault?
2nd - As far as Charles City, a finale rack broke apart when a defective Chinese made shell exploded in it. There was no "explosion" beyond the individual shells themselves. When you fire 10's of thousands of shells every year, THESE THINGS HAPPEN. J M was found NOT to be at fault by BOTH the insurance company AND the Iowa state fire marshal. I don't work for J M but I do know them to be very honest and competent. Afer 25 years of being in the full-time fireworks business, I can make that call better than most.
EVERY major fireworks company has accidents. when I say major, I mean firms that put on HUNDREDS of diaplays on the 4th of July alone. (The little guys that puts on a tiny handful of shows each year can boast how they have never had an accident. Let them say that after they have a few thousand shows under their belt.)
3rd - As far as a "massive" fireworks show, the main body of the show had nothing larger than 1.75" shells, the same that can be bought over the counter in WI. In addition to these, there were multi-shot "cakes" that are sold only to pros because of their high total charge weight. The individual shots are small, normally 1.25" or less. The finale include 2.5" shells but the NFPA distance tables were legit. If they were not, the insurance coverage would be invalid. Generally, idiots don't tend to run successful multi-million dollar companys like J M.
The fire guys absolutely deserve enourmous support and respect. (I'm a severe burn victim myself.) They are the ones that will put their lives on the line when it comes down to it but lets be fair to everyone here and not blow things out of proportion. There were WEEKS to work this thing out. I'm sure they'll get it right next year. We're all human.
Ken Miller
Write comment
smaller | bigger

busy
 
< Prev   Next >
RocketTheme Joomla Templates